By Josh Sager
The 2012 Republican presidential primary
process has become, at best, an embarrassing farce and at worst, the
death rattles of the Republican Party. I do not assert that the
regressive (I hate the "conservative" label as it is misleading and
instead prefer the political science definition of the Republicans) mindset or
ideal is any less valid or intelligent than the progressive ones, but that the
current right wing is no longer a policy based party.
I am a progressive, which means that I do not
subscribe to the social Darwinism of regressive beliefs but I don't
claim the regressive mindset to be illegitimate. I see the regressive ideals of
radical individualism to be dangerous to those who are less fortunate and in
many cases, the seeds of an authoritarian state. The eventual result of
individualism and social Darwinism is simply that the powerful will
eventually pull away from the rest of society. Social Darwinism parallels
biological Darwinism in that society begins to resemble the trees in a rain
forest: The taller trees (Top 10% of society) eventually block out the sun for
all those under them (Bottom 90% of society), and it gradually becomes nearly
impossible for new trees to grow above the canopy. The wealthy in society will
eventually consolidate all of the resources due to their level of capital and
control over the system. In a regressive system, the government doesn't address
social inequality and thus there is no real way for the poor to advance in
society; schools stay poor, jobs remain without benefits, and social mobility dries
up to a trickle. I see the eventual flaws in the regressive economic model as
deadly and thus prefer the progressive model, but this is just my point of
view. I have no more right to impose my views on others as they do to impose
theirs on me. In a democracy, everybody deserves a voice, regardless of
disagreements or partisanship.
I have three major issues with the current
Republican Party, all of which are illustrated by the primary process. Through
a combination of all three of these party-wide characteristics, the Republican Party
has become simply a vehicle by which wealthy interests can affect policy. In
the past, the Republican Party has stood for small
government, independence from centralized government, and a
"moral" set of values primarily based upon Judeo-Christian religion.
Whether or not you support the traditional values of the Republican Party, they
are based on fact and can be considered a coherent and consistent set
of policy goals. In recent years, the Republican Party has mutated due to
increased corporate involvement and funding into a party with
no consistent set of values other than the perpetuation of
the upward concentration of wealth.
- The
current Republicans have completely divorced themselves from the fact in
nearly every issue. Differing interpretations of the same facts is
inevitable, but the current right wing has simply decided to make up their
own set of facts to fit their narrative.
Whether the issue is scientific such as evolution or
social such as trickle down tax policy, the Republican party has completely
ceased to consider the objective facts. Science has near unanimously accepted
concepts such as evolution, global climate change, and the biological
determination of sexual orientation, while at the same time the Republicans
have near unanimously rejected these concepts. The same situation has happened
with social/economic issues such as tax policy, where the Republicans argue
that tax cuts are job creators. Evidence and history have shown that
deregulation and tax cuts don't automatically create jobs, just look at the
Bush years. The Republicans as a group are unwilling to accept any fact that
does not conform to their preconceived notions (confirmation bias)
which is fatal to the bi-partisan discussion. If one party is unwilling to
accept facts, what hope is there that they can agree upon anything with another
party who does?
Not every political party must accept facts to be
considered legitimate, but the orchestrated creation of alternative facts in
order to pander to a certain groups does destroy party legitimacy. The
Republicans are at best, an advocacy group for the rich and at worst, corporate
puppets. The creation of alternative facts is particularly destructive to low
information voters because they are often convinced to vote against their own interests.
- The
current Republicans cannot be reasoned or negotiated with; they would much
rather destroy the country than let it be run through compromise and
cooperation.
A vital part of politics in the USA
is compromise due to the separation of powers. One party may
control one part of the legislature while the other controls the rest, thus
they must find some common ground for government to function. In recent years,
the Republicans have steamrollered over the Democrats when in power and
obstructed when not to levels never before seen.
The current Republican Party seems unable
to compromise on any point and is often willing to
play Russian roulette with the country rather than strike a deal.
Even when a lack of compromise would harm everybody, the Republicans
are unwilling to capitulate even slightly, turning politics into a long term
hostage situation. As with any hostage situation: Those who are trying to
protect the hostage (the Democrats) are left capitulating to the demands of a
minority who are willing to kill the hostage (the American people) if their
demands are not met.
If the Republicans are willing to harm everybody if
their demands are not met, then who are they actually serving? The goal of
government is to serve the people, but in recent years the Republican ideology
has taken precedent over the welfare of the people. Either
the Republicans are corrupt in that they care more for helping the rich who
fund them than the entire country, or so ideologically extreme that they are
willing to be political suicide bombers for the cause of conservatism. When the
third problem with the Republican party is taken into account, the only logical
conclusion is the former conclusion rather than the latter.
- The
current Republicans have completely sold out to those with money and
power. While this problem is by no means exclusive to the Republicans, it
has become the primary function of the right wing to pander to the
rich.
In most political ideologies there are central
beliefs which are not situational, but rather universal. Each political
ideology has a set of values that differentiate them from the rest; the
universal Progressive platform includes a strong safety net, education,
regulations on corporations, and rights for all people in the country. The universal
Regressive platform includes individual freedom from government intervention,
low taxes, decreased regulation and personal choice over mandates.
In recent years, the Republicans have abandoned
their universal beliefs in all situations which don't benefit the
rich. Socialism and redistribution of wealth are evil, except when it is to
bail out the banks and corporations. Government control over people's lives is
unacceptable except where they disagree with the right wing mindset.
Ideological flexibility can be a good thing for compromise, but
in this particular case, it demonstrates a lack of principles. All of the right
wing ideologies are used for the express benefit of the rich at the detriment
of the poor. Capitalism for the poor, socialism for the rich is not
a consistent political message and demonstrated a lack of conviction
behind the message of the current right wing.
In the past, the regressive message has
been consistent, based upon facts, and not set in stone to the point where
suicide is preferable to compromise. Even Reagan raised taxes when the
need for revenue was important to the country. Compromise has been
common even for the most right wing politicians when the country would suffer
otherwise. Facts are not partisan, they are objective and the complete
rejection of reality by one party is a new development in our nation. In short,
Republicans have become the party of the rich and those who they can fool into
supporting them; the party of no and the party where death is preferable to
ideological impurity. The current Republican establishment is nothing like the
past regressives, but rather a corporatist tool that serves only themselves
and the rich.
Please Republicans, wake up and smell the
corruption. Your party is no longer a legitimate political party and if you
don't take it back, you will eventually wake up in a USA that you
don't recognize.